Nov. 20, 2025, NEW ORLEANS — For almost a 3rd of her life, Carolyn Monnie Cushenberry, 74, has been targeted on the First and Final Cease, the small bar that sits on the nook of Pauger and Marais Streets within the 7th Ward.
However now the bar and far of her life’s work has been offered from beneath her, by homeowners who felt like household to her. “I’m harm and I’m devastated,” mentioned Cushenberry, as she tried promote a beer cooler and tables on Fb Market, making ready for a probable closure. “It looks like my 20 years of being right here was snatched away from me.”
What eats at her isn’t that the constructing was offered, however the way it’s occurred: scant discover from the unique homeowners adopted by erratic habits from a brand new proprietor. Nobody actually is aware of what is going to occur subsequent, Pauger Avenue neighbors say.
Cushenberry’s trailblazing dad and mom and their Black-run bar room in Jim Crow New Orleans paved the best way for locations just like the First and Final Cease. However what is occurring on Pauger and Marais in the end displays the shaky state of Black bars in New Orleans in the present day — and the function of town’s excessive racial wealth hole in that cultural disaster.
The unsure future hits exhausting within the Black-masking Indian tribes which were based mostly on the bar for almost a century. “After I heard about it, I sat down and I cried,” mentioned Tyrone “Pie” Stevenson, 66, large chief of the Monogram Hunters tribe, which leaves the First and Final Cease on Mardi Gras morning in its new fits, gathers there on St. Joseph Evening, and holds common, usually weekly, “Indian practices” there to follow conventional music and dance as Mardi Gras approaches.
In 1970, as Stevenson sewed his first go well with at age 11, civil-rights fighter Jerome “Huge Duck” Smith picked him each week to deliver him to Indian follow in that constructing with the Yellow Pocahontas tribe, run by the revered Huge Chief Allison “Tootie” Montana.
Over time, the nook has change into a part of Indian lore. “Once we sing, we’re at all times speaking about Pauger and Marais,” Stevenson mentioned. “That’s the place we got here from.”
The place has run by no less than a dozen names and operators. It was the Pink Canary when Stevenson’s uncle, Alfred Dolliole, ran it within the mid-Nineteen Eighties. Evangeline Small operated it as Vangie’s Lounge within the late Nineteen Eighties. Stevenson additionally remembered when Louis J. “Junior” Early ran it with Jessie R. Williams within the Seventies, as J. & L’s Enjoyable Field. Earlier than that, it was the Pied Piper’s Bar run by Maryrose Hamilton. The Fortunate Star Lounge, run by Satelina Duplessis. Membership Avalon, operated by Alvin Chapital and William Monroe in 1961, Dolores Bellamy in 1964, and Rushell Zanders in 1968, in response to Louisiana Alcohol and Beverage Management board notices. Monroe additionally ran his building and roofing firm from the constructing within the mid-Sixties. A number of the older neighbors do not forget that earlier than that, within the mid-Fifties, it was referred to as the Blue Lamp Bar.
The bar’s present identify acquired its begin in 1995, when it was dubbed the First Cease Bar & Lounge by proprietor Milligan Corridor, remembered by neighbors as a retired Pepsi supply driver. Round that point, it was additionally briefly re-named Ernie Okay-Doe No. 2, as a result of it was being run by his widow Antoinette Okay-Doe, Cushenberry’s good pal.
But regardless of who ran it or named it, Indians noticed the identical 4 sacred partitions. “They acquired so many spirits in that place, of the Indians who paved the best way for me and everybody else,” Stevenson mentioned. “If God would permit spirits to indicate themselves in that constructing, we’d be surrounded by Indians.”
From barmaid to proprietor, in a single day
Tiny Carol Cushenberry, who stands about 5 ft tall and weighs possibly 100-pounds, first set foot into the slim bar 30 years in the past, when it was the First Cease. She got here there along with her pal Frank Cole, her fishing buddy, who lived throughout the road.
Quickly, she was employed as a barmaid by the bar’s proprietor, Albert C. Steward, who additionally lived upstairs in one of many constructing’s three residences. A couple of years later, when Steward acquired sick, she cared for him and saved the institution working whereas additionally staying in contact together with his son and daughter-in-law, who lived in Chicago.
When Steward died, his household held an enormous repast on the bar. Then they requested her to take over. “We might love you to have this,” mentioned his son, who offered her the bar and gave her a field of his dad’s ashes to maintain in a nook there. She and her husband Freddie Cushenberry purchased the contents from Steward’s household and signed a lease with the constructing’s homeowners, Al Reagle and his spouse, Virginia “Ginny Kay” Sortino Reagle.
On February 25, 2002, the Occasions-Picayune ran an advert from Freddie Cushenberry, a discover that he was making use of for a allow to promote alcoholic drinks at 1843 Pauger.
The couple dubbed it the First and Final Cease Bar and commenced paying weekly hire to the Reagles. For years now, regulars have been drawn to the place for its heat ambiance. Youngsters used to flock right here too, to a entrance window that’s now bricked in, the place the bar’s proprietors used to promote pickles and potato chips.
From Pauger Avenue, clients stroll by the crimson iron doorways and discover a lengthy wood bar lining the wall on the precise. On the left are wood bar chairs pulled as much as a row of small, waist-high tables. Within the again, there’s a pool desk, video poker machines, and an open area the place folks dance and sing throughout Indian practices.
Longtime clients greet one another with hugs and kisses earlier than putting a drink order with Cushenberry’s daughter, Trinette Monnie, 54, and taking a seat within the entrance. “Bars like ours undergo waves of consumers,” Monnie mentioned. “Some have died. Some have modified their lives and don’t dangle in bars anymore. Only some have caught with us the entire time.”
On most days, the First and Final Cease is a quiet spot with a jukebox that performs outdated R&B and jazz, excellent for its crowd of middle-aged regulars, each individuals who grew up within the seventh Ward and newcomers who simply moved there. Vacationers usually take selfies with Cushenberry, who has change into a legendary determine, referred to as “Totsie” by lots of her clients — a nickname her husband gave her due to her petite measurement. On Tuesday’s, the bar serves its hefty Huge Mouth Burgers, topped with sauteed onions and made by Cushenberry within the bar’s kitchen.
Tuesday, November 11 turned out to be the final day that the bar was open to serve drinks or burgers. But most clients who got here by the door hadn’t heard that Cushenberry would quickly be closing down. “This bar has been right here endlessly. And this information bothers me immensely,” mentioned Jerilynn Scott.
The bar was a dependable spot for each its clients and homeowners, who signed a brand new 10-year lease with the Reagles in 2023, with barely larger rents to regulate for rising taxes and insurance coverage, she mentioned.
Then in late September, Al Reagle referred to as Carol Cushenberry to inform her that he had dangerous information. “I’m promoting the constructing. I acquired a suggestion for it,” he mentioned.
The choice to promote got here as a shock to the Cushenberrys, who had been solely two years into their new lease. “My understanding was that I had first choice,” she mentioned. “When he and his spouse determined to eliminate it, I’d get it.”
She and her son, Tarikh Duckworth, a building contractor tried to achieve Reagle to make a suggestion. However inside days, it was too late. “It’s already offered,” Reagle instructed them.
Heated encounters with new proprietor
Cushenberry requested the brand new proprietor, Daniel Sellers, to honor the phrases of her current lease. That would occur provided that she began paying for legal responsibility and hearth insurance coverage insurance policies that the Reagles had at all times paid as a part of the lease, she mentioned. Then, on November 1, Sellers posted a hand-typed discover on the bar’s door, giving her 10 days to vacate the premises. He additionally shut off her lights on the major breaker and put a series on her door, locking her out.
Seeing Sellers and the discover, neighbors frantically referred to as Cushenberry. She arrived to search out Sellers leaving the bar, she mentioned. He instructed her he had folks coming to assist him throw the bar’s contents right into a dumpster. “He had me so upset. I used to be trembling,” she mentioned. “He was proper in my face.”
Twice throughout the confrontation, he referred to as her a n—– b—-, she mentioned. It’s an allegation that Sellers adamantly denied, saying he has by no means used the n-word in all of his 40 years.
Final week, The Lens acquired a letter despatched on Sellers’ behalf by lawyer David Band, alleging that The Lens’ reporting on this matter defamed Sellers. Band requested us to enhance our reporting with a extra particular protection. “It was a heated argument on a public road and no racial epithets had been used,” Band mentioned. Whereas The Lens stands by its reporting on the matter, we’re supplementing our reporting out of an abundance of warning.
Sellers and Cushenberry additionally differ on different key factors. She says she referred to as 911 on him; he says he referred to as 911 and ran on foot all the best way to the Treme as a result of she went into her automobile and grabbed a gun, an allegation she denies. He says he hasn’t been paid hire in two months; whereas Cushenberry mentioned that she paid him in money. He says that he had a hammer in his hand as a result of he was simply attempting to achieve the stucco that coated the historic constructing’s floor earlier than the bricks had been added to the outside; she says that she heard an affect close to her head and noticed that he’d used the hammer to make a dent right into a brick by the door as she walked onto the bar’s doorsill.
On November 1, when New Orleans Police Division officers arrived, they retrieved Sellers from Gov. Nicholls Avenue and conferred with each of them outdoors the First and Final Cease. The incident report notes that officers instructed Sellers “to report back to Civil District Court docket for correct eviction proceedings and to steer clear of mentioned property till eviction is secured.”
Regardless of that advisement from police, Sellers continues to indicate up outdoors the constructing. “It’s like he’s taunting her,” her son mentioned. The textual content messages that Sellers sends his mom vary from notes urging her to spare herself the “embarrassment” of going to the eviction court docket to 2 social-media movies displaying Black girls who’re offended at being evicted by deputies.
“The movies I despatched her? Guess what, that was fully unsuitable,” Sellers mentioned on Thursday night. “That’s immoral. That’s not a superb factor to do. However you already know what, the humanity in me, the evil within me, the a part of me that was not the very best habits, did that as a result of I’m extraordinarily annoyed that everyone needs to be the sufferer.”
He additionally says that her son, Duckworth, has threatened Sellers’ life.
On Tuesday night, November 18, Sellers walked out of the constructing’s alley and virtually ran right into a neighbor strolling house from the grocery. He was carrying some type of clippers and ran to his work van after he noticed her, she mentioned when interviewed by The Lens on Thursday evening. She’d referred to as Cushenberry about it at 5::32 p.m., the neighbor mentioned, checking her cellphone. Once they inspected the nook the place he’d been, a sliced cable was hanging off that facet of the constructing, she mentioned. When Duckworth walked your complete constructing on Thursday, he discovered a number of extra reduce cables, together with the one linked to the bar’s facet door digital camera.
Sellers mentioned he had nothing to do with the sliced cables. “Sure, I noticed the neighbor. The neighbor noticed me,” Sellers instructed The Lens. “I did what I wanted to do and I left.” He wanted to chop the lock on the facet gate, he mentioned.
‘Opening quickly’
5 days later, on November 7, trumpeter Kermit Ruffins posted a photograph of the First and Final Cease on Instagram. “Old-fashioned bar I simply acquired, opening quickly,” he wrote.
Nobody believes that Ruffins is behind her eviction. Cushenberry has identified Ruffins since he was a toddler. “I watched him develop up,” she mentioned.
Ruffins didn’t buy the constructing. Public information present that on October 1, Sellers purchased the place from the Reagles in a money sale for an undisclosed quantity.
The Reagles additionally personal the constructing at 1500 N. Claiborne Ave. that homes Kermit’s Treme Mom-in-Legislation Lounge, which Ruffins has leased and operated since 2012. And till 2007, the Reagles additionally owned the constructing at 1532 Ursulines St. that housed the bar Joe’s Cozy Nook.
The primary newspaper point out of the bar at 1843 Pauger St. got here simply after World Struggle II, in January 1946, when Lawrence Sortino, Virginia Reagle’s father, utilized to promote alcohol at a spot he named for his spouse, Sadie Demma Sortino. Sortino, later described because the operator of Fortunate Star Coin Co., a jukebox distributor, moved away from managing the place. By 1950, he was promoting to hire Sadie’s Bar and Restaurant, a “coloured” institution.
In neighborhoods just like the seventh Ward, the place Black masking Indians patronized groceries and bars run by Italian households, traditions merged. It’s due to these bonds that Indian tribes started popping out a second time annually, on St. Joseph’s Evening, the place they might rejoice the Catholic feast day sacred to native Italians and cease at Italian bars alongside the best way.
But few Black New Orleanians rose to possession. Although clients depend on beloved neighborhood figures like Cushenberry and Ruffins, neighborhood bars are incessantly owned by outdoors homeowners, who signal leases with bar homeowners to run the locations. Photographer L. Kasimu Harris touched on the fragility of those conventional Black-run institutions in his photographic sequence, “Vanishing Black Bars and Lounges.” As he wrote in his notes for the sequence, he has seen drastic adjustments in latest a long time. “Black bars in Black communities are turning white,” he wrote.
Throughout the First and Final Cease, whole residential blocks of the seventh Ward additionally modified arms throughout that point interval, to be rented out as AirBNBs and acquired up by neighborhood newcomers, usually white professionals who made greater than the working-class households who used to stay on these blocks.
A number of the newcomers have additionally change into regulars and Cushenberry enjoys the guests from all over the world, together with the band members of Jimmy Royal and the Regals, a British band that included a portray of a New Orleans constructing labeled “First and Final Cease” on the within centerspread of their CD jacket. An autographed copy sits behind the bar, signed “To Totsie. A lot love.”
The buyout, and the faces in in the present day’s seventh Ward, is an economics lesson in motion, illustrating wealth gaps inside the metropolis. Nationally, white households usually have six occasions the wealth of a Black households. It’s much more concentrated within the New Orleans space, a brand new research discovered. Right here, the ratio is 13 occasions white to Black, with median internet value for Black households standing at roughly $14,000, in contrast with $185,000 for white households. The biggest imbalance is among the many high 10% of households, the place roughly 9 of 10 households are white.
Rising insurance coverage insurance policies and utility payments have made possession rather more prohibitive for everybody throughout town. However for working-class residents, possession now appears just about not possible.
“From once I was 11 years outdated till now, all of the individuals who ran this bar didn’t personal it. They had been simply leasing it,” mentioned Pie Stevenson, who believes that Cushenberry is caught in the course of forces she can’t management. “Take a look at our most well-known Black-run bars. The bar managers can lease and be the face of one thing. But when they don’t personal it, that mild might go off at any time.”
Cushenberry, a toddler of the Black bar room
Some operators of Black-run bars do personal each their companies and their buildings. Amongst them are the Sportsman Nook Bar at 2nd and Dryades Avenue in Central Metropolis, which has been owned and run by the Elloie household because the Sixties, and Bullet’s Sports activities Bar on A.P. Tureaud Avenue, lengthy owned by Rollin “Bullet” Garcia Sr. – who introduced this summer time that he hoped to promote his institution.
Within the Treme, Cushenberry’s dad and mom, George “Crip” and Byrdies “Mama Bert” Monnie, had been thought-about trailblazers, who owned a dry cleaner’s on Basin Avenue and a boarding home on the nook of Marais Avenue and Ursulines Avenue the place they rented to well-known tenants together with musicians Okay-Doe and Dooky Chase. Then the couple purchased a constructing throughout from the boarding home, a grocery with residing quarters hooked up. They ran the grocery, Bert’s, at 1333 Ursulines, for just a few years earlier than turning it into what’s mentioned to be the neighborhood’s first Black-owned bar, referred to as Monnie’s.
The lot the place the grocery as soon as stood is now empty, overseen solely by a pecan tree planted by Mama Bert that towers over the property.
However Cushenberry vividly remembers life there, and the rhythms of working a bar.
As a toddler, she helped her mother load the icebox within the bar. She would stand on a stool to stir the tall pots of crimson beans and gumbo that fed many Boh Brothers crews throughout their lunch breaks. Folks nonetheless name her Mama Bert’s daughter.
Others name her Ms. Monnie. When that occurs, her clients look confused, she mentioned. “I inform them, ‘That’s my sixth Ward identify.’ In the event that they name Ms. Moonie, you already know they’ve identified me for a very long time.”
Now, when Trinette is shifting round city, folks say, “Hey, Ms. Carol’s daughter.”
Right here at Pauger and Marais, after their clients depart, Carol Cushenberry is usually awake. That’s when she pulls out her toolbox or her paintbrush to maintain up with the bar’s upkeep. She had employed crews for larger jobs, like re-wiring the constructing or fixing damaged pipes after a freeze. However extra usually, her son helps her make repairs. When Christmas is coming, she decorates and throws an annual celebration. “I’ve spent a lot on this constructing,” she mentioned. “I get the licenses. The payments are in my identify.”
Throughout latest bursts of late-night power, she refreshed the entrance bar’s white ceiling tiles with a coat of denim blue and he or she painted the flooring fire-engine crimson and. “She began with crimson doorways after which it acquired crimson throughout,” her daughter mentioned.
Prospects say that this little crimson jewel is an important a part of the seventh Ward. It’s additionally important to her mother’s id, Trinette Monnie mentioned. “She positively doesn’t wish to stroll away like this.”
This story was appended on December 11, in response to a letter despatched to The Lens from David Band, an lawyer for Daniel Sellers.
Associated
